|
|
|
names not numbers
More than 200 children, families, women and men
are held at any one time in Dungavel since it opened in September 2001.

The names and stories of those incarcerated
there are important because it gives us some idea of what
Dungavel Removal Centre really is - a travesty
of human rights on Scottish soil.
Knowing who is inside also reminds us of the ones who
go nameless, whose stories we don't know.
We have tried to include names and pictures where
possible.
There are stories of why people fled, what
happened them to during their incarceration, their struggle to be recognised as
human beings inside a system determined to strip them of their basic human
rights.
And there are stories of courageous people trying
to expose
the abuse of human rights at Dungavel.
Their stories also reveal the absolute zero
status accorded to 'asylum seekers' incarcerated in Dungavel on Scottish soil.
In reality they have no rights whatsoever. Any abuse of their rights cannot be
seen by the outside world. The Scottish Executive refuses to speak out on the
travesties going on inside Dungavel.
Some people think the campaigners are on the
outside. Actually, many are on the inside too, telling their stories with such
courage and at great risk to their own safety as well.
That is why the campaign must continue until
Dungavel is closed down for good.
AY FAMILY VICTORY
The
Ay family, who were held in the Dungavel detention centre for more than a year
before being deported to Germany, have been granted permission to stay in that
country. The Kurdish family, who said they were fleeing persecution in Turkey,
fought a long campaign to stay in the UK.
Commenting
on the recent decision by Germany to give leave to remain to the ay family,
Robina Qureshi, director of the antiracist charity , Positive Action in Housing,
said:
“We welcome the news that the ay family have been given leave to remain by
Germany and without having to be locked up in a detention centre. It is a tragic
indictment of UK asylum policy that Britain could not do the same but chose
instead to incarcerate and institutionalise the family in Dungavel for over a
year at a cost of hundreds of thousands of pounds. We call on the home Secretary
to review the flaws in his inhumane asylum policy so that genuine refugees can
remain in the Uk with their liberty intact, and especially in Scotland where
population decline is the fastest in Europe. To lock up whole families inside a
‘detention centre’ is nothing short of barbaric. How sad that this is the Ay
children’s experience of the Uk, and that their relationship with scotland was
as prisoners in a country whose leaders remained silent on their incarceration.”
See web page with drawings and writings by the Ay children
:
|

Babyan family from Maryhill, Glasgow reunited after Home
Office blunder
After being detained in Dungavel Removal Centre for four days, Artur Babyan
was released yesterday.
The Home Office spent hundreds of pounds on detaining Artur Babyan in Dungavel
Removal Centre. He was released following intervention of his lawyers Wilson
Terris and Co. who lodged a judicial review on his behalf. Artur and his family
now await a decision from the high court on their asylum claim.
The Babyan family fear they will be imprisoned if they are returned to
Azerbaijan.
Currently living in Maryhill, Artur was separated from wife and children and taken to Dungavel
around October 15. Mrs Babyan was then informed that she and her children will
be removed on Monday 18 October. In a statement Robina Qureshi, of Positive
Action in Housing, the charity which campaigned on behalf of the family, said:
"This family went through hell because of a Home Office blunder. Artur's wife
this family went through completely violates their human rights. Was it really
necessary for an immigration snatch squad to invade this young family's home at
dawn, remove the father and then proceed to threaten to detain his bewildered
and traumatised wife and children?
"We will be studying this case closely so that the Babyan family's claim for
asylum is heard without them being emotionally terrorised in the way they have
been these past five days."
A friend of the family writes:
"Artur Babyan is Armenian. He was born and lived in Azerbaijan. When
war has started between Armenians and Azer people he had to change his
name. His wife Nasirova Kifayat's nationality is Azeri. She also was
born and lived in Azerbaijan, together they have two children, Arzu (she
was born in Azerbaijan) and Michel (he was born in Scotland). When they
arrived to United Kingdom in August 2002 they asked for asylum, after
few weeks they were sent to Glasgow, but they solicitor was in London,
after while they case has been refused by Home Office saying that he did
not have documents to prove that his and his families life is in danger.
Then Artur gave more document (birth certificate, letter from doctor
etc). On the beginning of this year there was new law that where you
live you need to have solicitor near you, so Artur had to change his
solicitor and find one in Glasgow. Artur regularly phoned and
visited her to ask if there was any improvements, his last visit was 1-2
month ago and she said that his case still in progress. On Wednesday 13
October he went sign in the Home Office in Glasgow, and has been told
that his family is going to be deported, from that day his wife went to
see solicitor and signed some documents, also she asked for a letter
from Doctor because they daughter gets sick and Artur have really bad
headaches, Doctor refused to give them letter saying that he is too
busy, and when he give letter to solicitor he did not mention any thing
about they illnesses. Kifayat is really afraid, she does not know what
to do and who to turn to because if they go back to Azerbaijan, straight
from airport Azerbaijani authorities are going to take them to prison
and God knows what is going to happen to her and her children."
|
Urgent Action Alert
Can you help?
Mustafa Mohammed, 20 years old, Palestinian
Status: Has received visitors - currently establishing contact with
lawyers.
30-09-04 Mustafa has received visitors as a result
of this appeal. Lawyers are now being sought for him. His visitors say he is not well
and isn't eating properly. Definitely needs an
interpreter for anything important. They left him a little money for phone
calls. Send cards and messages of support to: Mustafa Mohammed, c/o HMP Greenock Gateside Greenock PA16 9AH SCOTLAND.
14 September 04 Mustafa
Mohammed was detained for six months in
Southampton , then sent to Greenock where he has been for five months. He had no
visitors until John identified him. He speaks Arabic
and very little English and has no visitors. He has no contact with a lawyer.
Mustafa is very confused and upset, according to John. He speaks only Arabic.
He said that he has been in this country for 2 years. He came from Ramallah
where all his family were killed and his house and locality demolished. He fears
he will be killed if he returns to Ramallah. He spent 3 months in Polmont Prison
(Young offenders prison for those under 21 years of age. Then he spent time at
Dungavel and Greenock Prison. He is desperate for visitors. If you wish to visit please call
Greenock Prison on 01475-787801 and request a visitors pass . Send
cards and messages of support to: HMP Greenock Gateside Greenock PA16 9AH SCOTLAND.
Click here to make a donation
Rasta, 32
years old, Angola
Status:
Freed on zero bail - October 2004
Rasta was
in Dungavel a year. He arrived in Folkstone and after a short time was
arrested and taken to Dover Detention Centre. Aged 32. From Angola. He
was a policeman and his father was in the police too. There was civil
unrest and violence in the country and his family was involved. His mum
and dad were killed and he was beaten- up and was forced to flee the
country. His sisters and brother are still there and he doesn't know how
they are.
Aven Hung, 30 years old, Chinese
FREED Friday 8 October

After 27 months
of detention, Aven Hung was unceremoniously released from Dungavel
Removal Centre on Friday 8 October. Throughout his detention he remained
strong and resilient with the support of the Dungavel befriending Group.
At the eleventh hour, Paddy Hill (of the Birmingham Six) stepped in to
provide Aven a place to stay short term. He will then go to stay with
another family once it has been authorised by the Immigration. Aven
cannot be returned to china as they do not accept returning asylum
seekers. So what was immigration doing keeping him that long inside
Dungavel? Yet they were eager to release him on Friday.
Saturday 2 October, 2004:
Julia Gulshan Babayeva and
Family, Azerbaijan:
Julia and family free at last:
After a two week campaign to stop the deportation and detention of Julia
Babayeva and her sons, Alex and Aziz, the family were granted a court petition
to resume their asylum claim. They were released on Friday from Tinsley House,
Gatwick Airport.
The Dungavel Bail fund, led by Peter Mullan and set up by Positive Action in
Housing, stepped into provide a cautioner and bail funds of £500 provided by
supporters in the last week.
The campaign had to act
quickly as the family were in danger of losing their home as the National
Asylum Support Service were going to terminate their tenancy on Monday 4
October. This would have meant that
they could not be released as all NASS support would then be terminated. Inside
detention, the family received over 50 cards and letters.
Robina Qureshi, Director of Positive Action in Housing,
the charity which led the campaign to release Julia and her children, said:
"Julia and her family are free because of the
solidarity of everyone who took action to highlight her case and get her and
her family back the basic human right of liberty to fight their case. We want
to thank them first of all. There will be more people like Julia and we will
show that solidarity again with the next case and the ones after that.
"The Home Office spent almost £5,000 needlessly
detaining the Babayeva family for the past two weeks. They are wasting huge
amounts of taxpayers' money on hounding refugees simply to prove the Home
Secretary is getting tough. This bully boy treatment is absolutely unnecessary.
In contrast, over the past three years, Gulshan threw herself into doing
hundreds of hours of voluntary work. If she had been allowed by the Home Office
to find work, she would have, if only to stand on her own two feet and support
her kids. Yet, she tried to get as close to the world of work as possible."
"We need Gulshan and her sons, as friends,
neighbours, workers, and as future generations to make up for Scotland's
declining population - the fastest in Europe. Gulshan and her family were doubly
persecuted, firstly by their own country, and then by ours when they claimed
asylum. Scotland is complicit in persecuting its future lifeblood and that
legacy may come to haunt future generations. It's time for a humane refugee
policy rather than this cat and mouse game called asylum and immigration
policy."
Julia and her family
were released thanks to the hard work of her lawyers, Grace McGill of Wilson
Terris & Co. and the many people who supported and donated towards Julia's
appeal for freedom. It's because of the many individuals who came forward to
express their outrage, call the family, write letters, cards and take action
that Julia and her children are now free. Thank you for caring and showing your
solidarity with the family. Julia, Alex and Aziz returned to Glasgow's
Sighthill, their home for the past three years at 2 am on Saturday 2nd October.
But the story doesn't
end there. The family's joy
at being released was hampered when they had to wait almost an hour before the
concierge would hand over their house keys. When they got to their flat their
front door had been broken in. Their home had been burgled and completely
trashed. A television which Julia paid £5
for in the local Sunday market was stolen.
Julia's personal jewellery - given to her by her late husband, who was killed by
Azerbaijani soldiers for refusing to kill Armenians in the Karabach war - was
stolen. Alex's
prized computer given to him by the Princes Trust for computing studies at
Glasgow North College was also stolen. The house smelled awful because when the
immigration snatch squad left they turned off all the electrics. As a result all
the food in the freezer and fridge was completely destroyed. After all they have
been put through, the family are devastated. Their total life savings amount to
£30.
Click here for Julia Gulshan's campaign page.
16th September
2004: John Oguchuckwu, 27 years old, Nigerian is FREE
John was freed today - Thursday 16 September 2004 - after a
public campaign to raise his bail money. In the past nine months John Oguchuckwu
has been held at Dungavel immigration centre, Lanarkshire, Greenock Prison and
the Colnbrook centre, Middlesex. Supporters, including film director Peter
Mullan, Gary Lewis, The Quakers, Dungavel Befriending Group, Beth Junor and many
many others were able to raise £2,300 to secure his release. The 27-year-old
former trainee priest is fighting deportation from the UK. He was denied asylum,
but has remained in the country since he launched a civil action to sue security
officers who he claimed assaulted him while he was being deported at Heathrow
Airport in December. Mr Oguchuckwu, whose hearing was held in Glasgow, was
previously at the Dungavel centre for six months, but also spent several months
in Greenock Prison after there were fears he may have attempted to commit
suicide. Most recently, he had been in Colnbrook immigration centre in
Middlesex. Following the hearing, Mr Oguchuckwu said he was "very happy" and
"alright".
"What I wanted for nine months is
freedom, I thank the Dungavel bail fund from the depths of my heart and all the
people, everyone, who helped me and ask God to bless them. For nine months I was
in a place of steel and locked doors and my heart was becoming so sad and low.
Today I am free and my heart feels God's light."
Peter Mullan hit out at government treatment. Mr Mullan, who
directed the Magdalene Sisters, said what happened to Mr Oguchuckwu was an
"injustice of the highest order".
"All these people have been caught in a Catch-22 - when as a
consequence of detention they suffer mental health problems," he said. "It then
gives the government license to put them into prison, where their mental health
will suffer even more. "The fact that people give money demonstrates that
Scottish people are more compassionate than our so-called governments."
Fellow Scots director Ken Loach also gave money to the bail
fund.
Robina Qureshi, of the charity Positive Action in Housing,
said:
"He is now free to continue his civil action and fight for
his right to refuge through a decent set of lawyers."
Mr Oguchuckwu has instructed his solicitors to prepare a
civil action following the alleged incident at Heathrow. His legal team argued
that removing him from the UK while the case was pending would breach his right
to a fair hearing. Read background to this case.
9th September
2004: Reading this, you might almost forget that John Oguchuckwu and others
like him, are refugees, not criminals.
John was
'detained' in Dungavel Removal Centre for 8 months. John alerted the press to
the suicide of 23 year old Vietnamese man Tung Wang. Tung Wang had hung himself
inside a toilet at Dungavel. John became severely depressed.
He was
transferred to Greenock Prison in july. When his story came to light, the
authorities claimed John was violent. However, Greenock Prison's psychiatric
report stated that John was taken to Greenock because of concerns about his
mental state. John said:
"The other
prisoners keep asking me what I have done. I say I haven’t done anything. They
ask me “how long are you serving?” and I say “I don’t know, I did not commit any
crime, I don’t know for how long I am in here”. They are annoyed for me to be in
prison.”
On Saturday 4
September, five days before his bail hearing was due to take place in Glasgow,
John was taken on a ten hour journey to Colnbrook Immigration Removal Centre in
London. This 'centre' is modelled on a high security category b prison. Each
cell is designed to hold two detainees. There is a toilet built into the cell
which is only half partitioned and does not have a door, not affording detainee
proper privacy. You can contact or visit Andre Aliev at: B Wing, Colnbrook
Immigration Removal Centre, Colnbrook Bypass Longford, West Drayton, Middlesex
UB7 0HB Tel: 020 8607 5200. His lawyer was not informed of the move.
The bail hearing
took place on Thursday 9 September. John was not present. The Adjudicator did
not accept the terms put forward for bail. Another cautioner and accommodation
provider had to be found in Scotland. The hearing was withdrawn.
A new bail hearing has been set for Thursday 16 September 2004 at 10 am.
26 August 2004: Two asylum seekers have sewn
their lips together and started a hunger strike in Greenock Prison. Andre
Aliev is Russian and has been detained since January 2003. He was
transferred from Dungavel to Greenock Prison in August 2004 where he is on
hunger strike. Vasil Gabbes, a Palestinian man, is also on
hunger strike. We do not know how long he has been detained. Both men were transferred to the jail from the
Dungavel detention centre. The Scottish Prison Service (SPS) would not comment
on individual cases. 27 year old John Oguchuckwu was sent to Greenock
prison indefinitely because he became suicidal after spending EIGHT months in
Dungavel. Oguchuckwu’s lawyers point out that he turned “whistleblower”
following Mr Tung Wang’s suicide in July 2004 and rang refugee support groups to
let them know about the Vietnamese man’s death. ( A fatal accident inquiry is to
be held into Wang’s death). Just a few days later, Oguchuckwu was moved to
Greenock. Robina Qureshi, of Positive Action in Housing, criticised
the Home Office. She said the men were being treated like criminals and should
not have been transferred to the jail. Asylum seekers are usually held at
Dungavel detention centre in Strathaven, Lanarkshire, while their claims are
evaluated. The response of the Home Office is to simply dump them in a prison
alongside convicted criminals. It is understood that the Russian man was taken
to Dungavel in January 2003 and transferred to Greenock jail two weeks ago. She
said: "Since then he has gone on hunger strike and sewn his lips up, as has
another Palestinian asylum seeker, whose name we don't know. "This is not about
people who have been left in Dungavel for a matter of days, they have been left
for up to one-and-a-half years to basically rot and that's leading them to such
despair that they are considering suicide as their only option. "The response of
the Home Office is to simply dump them in a prison alongside convicted
criminals." She said it was wrong for asylum seekers to be effectively punished
by the system while their claims were processed, then put into prison. There are
arrangements in place in exceptional circumstances where the SPS can accept
asylum seekers SPS spokeswoman A spokeswoman for the SPS said: "There are
arrangements in place in exceptional circumstances where the SPS can accept
asylum seekers. "They are accepted only in exceptional circumstances under the
agreed protocol between the SPS and the Immigration Service." The Home Office
too declined to comment on individual cases. But a spokeswoman said: "The Home
Secretary's commitment to end the routine use of prison accommodation to hold
immigration detainees has been fulfilled and the practice ended in January 2002.
"It was made clear at that time that exceptions would have to be made for
reasons of security and control, i.e. because an individual could threaten and
disrupt the orderly working of the immigration centre, the staff or other
detainees." Ms Qureshi also raised the case of a Nigerian man she said was
recently transferred from Dungavel to prison because he had suicidal tendencies.
"These people are innocent, they are not criminals," Ms Qureshi went on. "The
Home Office clearly sees no difference between Dungavel and Greenock Prison
because it is using them as part of the overall detention system." The Scottish
Socialist Party called on the Scottish Executive to make a statement on the use
of Greenock Prison to hold asylum seekers. SSP justice spokesman Colin Fox said
Justice Minister Cathy Jamieson should address the Scottish Parliament as "a
matter of urgency". He said: "The use of Scottish jails to hold asylum seekers
who have committed no offence and who have not been charged with any crime is an
extremely serious development. "The executive can no longer remain silent when
its ministers are now directly involved in the way that asylum seekers are being
treated in Scotland."
Source
22 August 2004: A 27-year-old refugee
priest from Nigeria, John Oguchuckwu,
was sent to Greenock prison indefinitely because he became suicidal after
spending eight months in
Dungavel. Oguchuckwu’s imprisonment has been condemned as illegal by his
lawyers. Supporters say he was moved to Greenock as Dungavel feared that another
suicide among inmates would ruin its already internationally tarnished
reputation. In an interview with the Sunday Herald from Greenock prison,
Oguchuckwu begged to be released. Photographic evidence shows that he had
previously been beaten – he alleges the assault was by immigration guards at
Heathrow airport. The Home Office and Scottish Prison Service (SPS) have both
been branded “liars” for claiming that Oguchuckwu was sent to Greenock prison
because he was violent after the Sunday Herald was given details of a
psychiatric report which states that Oguchuckwu was transferred because he was
threatening to kill himself. Oguchuckwu’s lawyers point out that he turned
“whistleblower” following Wang’s suicide and rang refugee support groups to let
them know about the Vietnamese man’s death. Just a few days later, Oguchuckwu
was moved to Greenock. There have also been a number of other suicide attempts
in Dungavel. Wang’s suicide caused Oguchuckwu to spiral into depression and
consider taking his own life. Speaking to the Sunday Herald from Greenock prison
by phone, Oguchuckwu said: “I was told that I was moved because I was suicidal.
I wasn’t threatening or violent to any officers or other inmates. The Home
Office is lying if it says that about me. “At the time I was just so down that I
actually was passing out. I was feeling very low. I was clinically depressed. At
one point I didn’t eat for two weeks. I was moved to Greenock three weeks ago.
When they moved me I was beginning to get better. “An officer in Greenock prison
told me they’d taken me here because Dungavel couldn’t do proper suicide
watches.” Despite his mental state, Oguchuckwu says he as not put on suicide
watch when he was transferred to Greenock. He is now in a shared cell and mixes
with criminals, despite having never committed a crime. “I didn’t commit any
crime,” Oguchuckwu said. “Why am I in this place? Everyone here is a criminal. I
am not. I feel very depressed again. This move has taken me from bad to worse.” In Nigeria, Oguchuckwu’s mother, father and sister were killed in sectarian
violence between Christians and Muslims. As a student priest, Oguchuckwu’s life
was threatened. “If I’m deported I’ll be killed,” he said. “Nothing can be as
bad as this. Even happiness is poison when you are in prison. I feel like I am
going crazy.” Oguchuckwu found a girlfriend when he came to the UK and set up
home in Manchester. His interview with the Sunday Herald was cut short when a
prison warder in Greenock ordered him to hang up the phone as he was talking to
a journalist. The Home Office and SPS said refugees were not transferred from
detention centres like Dungavel to prisons like Greenock unless they posed a
threat to security and were violent with other inmates or staff. “We do not move
people because they are suicidal,” a Home Office spokesman said. However, he
refused to go into the precise details of why Oguchuckwu was moved. The cases of
transferred refugees are reviewed monthly. The SPS said a refugee could
technically be kept in jail until they were deported, if they were deemed to
have not changed their behaviour. No court order is needed to move a prisoner
from Dungavel to a prison. Instead, an application is made by the immigration
service to the SPS. The SPS said the application would be turned down if it was
seeking to move a refugee because they were suicidal. An SPS spokesman said:
“There are agreed criteria on transfers. If someone said they were suicidal,
that is categorically not a reason to transfer.” A senior prisons source added:
“Oguchuckwu was transferred as he had shown violence towards staff.” However,
Jelina Rahman, one of the lawyers acting for Oguchuckwu, revealed the details of
a psychiatric report, dated August 6 and compiled on Oguchuckwu when he arrived
in Greenock, which reads: “He has been transferred from Dungavel as there were
concerns with regard to deliberate self-harm.” Oguchuckwu supporters say this
shows that the SPS and the Home Office have been caught out in blatant lies.
Rahman said she is launching a civil claim on behalf of Oguchuckwu following the
beating he allegedly received from guards in January. “He was assaulted at
Heathrow after he was taken from Harmondsworth detention centre to be deported,”
said Rahman. He had attempted suicide twice in Harmondsworth. “After this
beating, Mr Oguchuckwu felt suicidal and was then taken to Dungavel.”
Immigration bail was refused, said Rahman, as Oguchuckwu’s girlfriend – a single
mother – could not raise the £5000 required to get him out. There will be
another hearing in a few weeks. Rahman says she will take the case to the Court
of Session if bail is refused. Rahman said the psychiatric report contradicted
the government’s version of events, adding: “There is no mention in the
psychiatric report of any violence. If he was violent, then why did the
psychiatrist write a different story in his report? This is a potentially
suicidal man who has been in jail for a month with criminals.” Rahman also
pointed out that legal precedent states that while any court proceedings are
on-going – such as the civil suit against the guards who Oguchuckwu says
assaulted him – a person may not be deported from the UK. “His detention in
Greenock prison is illegal,” said Rahman. “He was removed from Dungavel
arbitrarily and on a whim. The proper courts were not involved. Mr Oguchuckwu
has the same right to a fair hearing as anyone else.” Irène Nembhard, another
lawyer acting for Oguchuckwu, has written to the Home Office saying that a
judicial review of her client’s case is imminent. “We see cases like this over
and over again with black men in prison. When they get depressed, they are
labelled violent .” John Razik, a Christian Iraqi who was detained with
Oguchuckwu in Dungavel, said: “ He never hurt anyone. Anyone who says he is
violent is a liar. He should be free.” Razik, who was persecuted in Iraq because
of his faith, tried to kill himself “many, many times” while in Dungavel. He was
only released from the detention centre two months ago. “I hurt myself because I
was in detention and I wanted to die,” he said. Razik’s arms are criss-crossed
with cuts from suicide attempts. Razik, who plans to bring a case against
Dungavel for unlawful imprisonment, also claims that he was beaten by
immigration guards and accused of being violent. (Source: Sunday Herald)
Aug 14, 2004:
Arshad Suhail Masih
was living in Glasgow for nearly two years, appealing against the refusal of his
asylum application. Arshad, a Christian, fled Pakistan after being threatened by
certain Muslims who accused him of blasphemy. Glasgow police stopped the car
Arshad was driving in because the driver was not wearing a seatbelt. The police
found out that Arshad and two of his friends are asylum seekers. The immigration
authorities then interviewed Arshad and his friends for three hours, finally
instructing them to appear at the National Asylum Support Service (NASS) in
Glasgow the following Monday. On his appearance there Arshad was arrested and
imprisoned in Dungavel. His friends from the Pakistani Christian community are
angry and bewildered. They have set up a group, Voice for the Voiceless, who
marched and protested outside the NASS offices last week. For Arshad,
deportation to Pakistan is tantamount to a death sentence. They intend to carry
on with the campaigning until they get justice. Send messages of support to
Voice for the Voiceless on 07904 083 058
Aug 11 2004: A LIVERPOOL woman is planning to
follow her husband back to a war-ravaged country if the British government
refuse to let him stay here. Millisa Masali-Monga, 25, is begging Home Office
officials not to deport husband of three years Patrick back to the Democratic
Republic of Congo. Mr Masali-Monga, 29, was detained by immigration
officials in Liverpool and sent to the Dungavel immigration removal centre in
Ayrshire, Scotland. He fled the Democratic Republic of Congo after his father, a
political activist, was shot dead by a rebel gang nearly five years ago. After a
savage civil war the country is now overrun by warlords. Fearing the same fate
as his father Mr Masali-Monga came to England four years ago and claimed
political asylum. He married in October 2001 and the couple set up home in
Wavertree. Two appeals against a Home Office decision to throw Mr Masali-Monga
out of the UK failed. Speaking from the immigration centre Mr Masali-Monga said:
"I do not want to go back to my country because I am scared I will be killed.
"All we want is to be allowed to live together in Liverpool in peace." It is not
yet known when Mr Masali-Monga will be sent back to the Democratic Republic of
Congo. Source: liverpool echo
August 11, 2004: Arshad Suhail Masih is
one of the many refugee prisoners held at Dungavel prison near Glasgow.
Arshad has been living in Glasgow for nearly two years, appealing against the
refusal of his asylum application. Arshad, a Christian, fled Pakistan after
being accused him of blasphemy. Glasgow police stopped the car Arshad was
driving in because the driver was not wearing a seatbelt. The police found out
that Arshad and two of his friends are asylum seekers. The immigration
authorities then interviewed Arshad and his friends for three hours, finally
instructing them to appear at the National Asylum Support Service (NASS) in
Glasgow the following Monday. On his appearance there Arshad was arrested and
imprisoned in Dungavel. His friends from the Pakistani Christian community are
angry and bewildered. They have set up a group, Voice for the Voiceless, who
marched and protested outside the NASS offices last week. For Arshad,
deportation to Pakistan is tantamount to a death sentence. They intend to carry
on with the campaigning until they get justice.
July 26, 2004:
More asylum seekers in Dungavel Detention Centre in Lanarkshire could kill
themselves because they feel they have no hope according to one detainee. It
follows the suicide at the weekend of a 22 year old Vietnemese man who hung
himself. He had been transferred from Harmondsworth in London. South African
asylum seeker Sarah Jane Richards who's currently in Dungavel says the man
had been detained for over a year and simply gave up hope of being released. (STV)
23 July 2004 -
Mr Tung Wang,
a 22 year old Vietnamese man, committed suicide by hanging himself at Dungavel
Removal Centre. The 23-year-old man, who had been switched from the
Harmondsworth centre at Heathrow Airport to the Lanarkshire unit, was found in a
toilet by staff on Friday night. The man, who has not been named, had lived in
Germany before coming to the UK earlier this year. Home Office officials
confirmed that someone had died at Dungavel but refused to go into any further
detail. It is understood the young man, who is thought to be from Vietnam, was
in the centre unaccompanied. It was not known if he has family at the English
detention centre. It is alleged
that the death of Tung Wang was caused by the Home Office issuing him with a
deportation order back to Vietnam. Serious physical and mental mistreatment of
asylum seekers is alleged, by campaigners, both in detention and in the process
of deportation. Home Secretary Blunkett visited Dungavel this month and
described conditions there as 'entirely satisfactory'. A spokeswoman for
Strathclyde Police confirmed the death, adding: 'There are no suspicious
circumstances.'Length of detention: Unknown.
July 3, 2004 - John Razek Khaled,
34, was released from
Dungavel Removal Centre after spending 25
months in detention. During
this time he slashed his wrists on numerous occasions. The Home Office
claim he is from Egypt because his mother is an Egyptian. But he has never even
been there. He has never tried to abscond and the UK authorities do not deport
people to that country (Iraq) because of the instability there. A Home Office
spokes-woman would not comment on John's detention (January 2004) but
said: "Enforced returns to Iraq will begin again when the situation is right".
July 2, 2004
- A female Asylum seeker
detained at Dungavel, needing hospital treatment was transferred to Hairmyres
Hospital in East Kilbride, handcuffed to a security guard. During her stay at
the hospital, according to a hospital worker, the asylum seeker was chained 24
hours a day. This was in complete breach of Article 3 of the European
Convention on Human Rights, the European Court of Human Rights, ruled in
November 2003 that the chaining/handcuffing of patients in hospitals was
unacceptable.
The woman, in her 20s and from
Cameroon, was kept in handcuffs at Hairmyers Hospital in East Kilbride,
Lanarkshire, for a serious medical procedure. They were only removed so she
could visit the toilet but even then she had guards with her. She was returned
to the notorious Dungavel Detention Centre in Lanarkshire yesterday, home while
her application for residency in the UK is processed. The woman, whose identity
is known to the Scottish Mirror, was taken to Hairmyers on Tuesday morning. She
spent all 48 hours of her stay there shackled and watched at all times by two
security guards. A horrified hospital worker, who contacted us on the condition
of anonymity, said: "Even when she was being examined by the doctor before her
operation, the two guards stayed. She then got stripped and changed to go to the
operating theatre. When the porter wheeled her down to the operating theatre on
the trolley, the guards were still with her. One of the guards had their hand
under the sheet. When she was taken into theatre, she was cuffed. She was
definitely still handcuffed when she received her general anaesthetic. "She was
knocked out. When she came in her clothes were dirty and there was some blood on
her shorts. "Her hair was greasy and matted. She looked like she hadn't been
given the chance to get a wash in days. "All of the staff were outraged at the
way the guards had to be by her side for 24 hours a day." A Home Office
spokesman said: "Physical restraint is sometimes necessary if the detainee has a
history of violent behaviour or poses a risk to themselves or others." (Source:
The Mirror)
July 2, 2004:
A YOUNG refugee mother taken from her Leeds home to a
controversial Scottish detention centre says she is fighting for her life.
Zenab Traore fears she will be killed if she is sent back to her native
Guinea. Immigration officers and police swooped on the young mum's home in
Harehills, Leeds, in a dawn raid at the end of last month. The 24-year-old was
taken away along with her 15-month-old
daughter Mariam. They are now
being held in the Dungavel detention centre in Lanarkshire from where
immigration officials intend to deport them next Tuesday. But the young mum said
she was terrified of returning to the West African country, which she fled two
years ago when her family were killed by marauding rebels from neighbouring
Liberia. Speaking from Dungavel, she said: I don't know what will happen to me
and my baby if I go back. It is making me very stressed - I can't sleep and I am
so confused and tired. I want to fight this but I have no money to get a
solicitor to help me. Zenab, who has been diagnosed as suffering from
post-traumatic stress disorder, lost her appeal against her failed asylum claim
in March last year. She said she was told by her solicitor in London an appeal
would be made to the High Court but found out last month the firm had had failed
to carry out its promise. Friends in Leeds said they were concerned for the
young family's welfare. Shocked John Ward, who taught English to Zenab at Thomas
Danby College, Leeds, said: She was quiet but always very friendly. I was really
shocked when I heard what had happened to her. The manner in which she has been
taken away and locked up is appalling. This is a young mum, not a criminal.
Immigration officers have already tried to deport the family twice since their
detention. On the second occasion Zenab claimed she was assaulted by immigration
officers and made a statement to Scottish police. Zenab has been held at
Dungavel since the end of May with her baby. The controversial detention centre has been
besieged by protesters since it opened and has been roundly criticised for
locking up the children of asylum seekers. At the parents' group attended by
Zenab and Mariam there were messages of support for the family. Marsha Green, a
support worker at Sure Start Harehills, said other parents were praying for her
safe return.(Source Yorkshire Evening Post).
25 June 2004:
Maxamuub Cawed, 25, was locked in solitary at Dungavel Detention Centre -
for protesting against the detention of kids. He had tried to organise a peace
protest at the centre, which he compares to America's Death Row. But hard-line
bosses at the former Lanarkshire prison got wind of his plan - and immediately
segregated him from fellow inmates. The calculated crackdown was last night
branded a "gross breach of human rights" by leading critics of the asylum seeker
base. In an exclusive interview with the Scottish Mirror, Maxamuub said: "I feel
like I am on Death Row. "I am scared for my future because of the uncertainty in
my life. My freedom means everything to me as it does to everyone in Dungavel."
He had been protesting against the imprisonment of kids like little Misheel
Narantsogt when he was singled out. Last night, Home Office officials coldly
confirmed they had isolated Maxamuub from fellow refugees on Monday. And a
spokesman said: "He was asking people to demonstrate with him and some detainees
informed staff. "The protest never really got off the ground. But he has been
taken away from the others." Maxamuub revealed he fears for his future as he
languishes in the detention centre - but more so for the children there. He
said: "There are about 90 people or more here at the minute and many more in the
family unit, where there must be at least 10 children. "They treat us the way
they want to treat us and sometimes it feels like we have no human rights. "The
guards treat us well here but we have no freedom and we are rarely let out of
our rooms." Under the European Convention on Human Rights, everybody has the
right to freedom of expression and freedom of association. But rules vary for
prisoners and people held in detention centres. Maxamuub arrived in the UK from
Somalia, Africa, three years ago after fleeing its fierce civil war. He
spotted the Mirror's successful campaign to free eight-year-old gala princess
Misheel Narantsogt from Dungavel last week and contacted us from behind bars.
Rule 40 of the Home Office rules for detention centres allows a detainee to be
separated "in the interests of security or safety". But bosses must seek
approval from the Home Secretary if they are removed for more than 24 hours. A
Home Office spokeswoman confirmed there had been no violence and said the
situation was being monitored. She added: "It was necessary to remove him from
association." (Source: The Mirror).
June 18, 2004:
A
MONGOLIAN family which had been locked up in Dungavel and faced imminent
deportation will be released this morning from the Lanarkshire detention centre
after a legal move, campaigners said early today. The decision means
eight-year-old Misheel Narantsogt
will be able to appear as the princess
at the lord mayor's parade in Liverpool next month.
Aamer Anwar, the family's
lawyer, said they would be freed after a fresh asylum claim was submitted
yesterday, based on the fact the government could not guarantee their safety in
Mongolia, which has a record of human rights abuses. He said: "They must stop
the removal direction because this is a fresh asylum claim, the central basis of
which is that because of the international publicity of this family their lives
are under threat from the Mongolia security apparatus." Robina Qureshi, director
of Positive Action in Housing, the charity which led the campaign to free the
family, said: ''The family are overjoyed at this new turn of events and it means
that they can return to Liverpool and Misheel will get her dress fitting and be
the princess at the parade on July 10. Her 17-year -old brother,
Evsaana, will
also be able to sit his English exam." Misheel's mother, Sinee, 37, and her
husband, Jugder, 38, said: "We're so happy and thank you to everyone who helped
us in Scotland and Liverpool. My husband and
I looked out of the window and saw the beautiful Scottish country through the
barbed wire and steel fence, and Scotland reminded us of the Mongolian landscape
and we could not see the green countryside or walk through it, just saw it
through the steel fence and that made me sad." Ms Qureshi said the release was a combination of the Mr Anwar's
work and publicity
generated
around the family. She added: "If it weren't for the excellent campaigning and
speedy legal representation, they would probably be deported. It is shocking
that the first minister chose not to speak out yet again. Asylum might be
reserved, but it doesn't mean that Dungavel is invisible. The Scottish
conscience will not rest until children are freed from Dungavel." (Source:
The Herald)
16 June, 2004: Perhaps the worst
innovation of the current Labour government is that, unlike any other government
in Europe, it now detains whole families, including young children and babies,
and pregnant women. At the end of 2002 115 women were detained. The Home office
gives no figures on the number of children, apparently considered non-persons,
detained. Because of the inability of UKDS to protect the women and families
detained in Harmondsworth, they have been moved elsewhere. Yarl's Wood was
reopened in September 2003 for women and apparently, in future, children.
Children and their mothers are detained at Dungavel, Tinsley and Oakington. Some
children have been moved from mainstream schools, where they were much
appreciated by their friends and teachers, and have been locked up in
prison-like conditions, at Dungavel for example, for months on end, in spite of
numerous protests, in the House of Lords and elsewhere. Pregnant women have
inadequate medical attention. Mothers have to queue for hours to receive
powdered milk or nappies, which are allocated one at a time. A report by Bail
for Immigration Detainees, A Crying Shame:Pregnant Asylum Seekers and Their
Babies in Detention, gives a harrowing account based on interviews with some of
these women.
source
30 April 2004:
Yarl’s Wood : The Prison Ombudsman 30th April
2004 report showed that between Oct 2003 and Jan 2004, the incidence of use of
force at Yarl’s Wood (all women detainees) was by far the highest of all Removal
Centres - twice that of the second highest incidence at Dungavel and more
than 5 times that of Dover (all male detainees).
Source
28 April 2004, 12:00pm: Baroness Scotland
of Asthal, a Home Office minister, has stated that Dungavel detention centre, in
Lanarkshire, currently holds six families, with ten children, four of whom are
of school age. source
1 March 2004:

Mutuamba Jolie Ntenda from the Democratic
Republic of Congo (DRC) is 24 years old and fled two years ago. At the beginning
of 2001, she worked in the palace of then President Laurent Kabila while her
husband Rashidi Mizele Casereca served as his bodyguard. On January 16 the
dictator was assassinated. Newspaper cuttings suggest Rashidi pulled the trigger
and later that same day he was himself killed. Jolie was Rashidi's second wife -
she has the marriage certificate to prove it - and she maintains she knew
nothing of her husband's alleged involvement in a planned coup. Jolie swas
arrested and imprisoned in Makala prison. She claims she was tortured and
regularly raped by guards there. Two raped her four times each. After ten months
of incarceration, an old army colonel friend of her dead husband warned her she
was due to be executed. He arranged her escape, smuggled her out of prison and,
after fleeing to the UK, Jolie claimed asylum and settled in Derby. Jolie's soft
spoken, gentle manner conceals a resolve of steel. Her ten months in prison must
have been an almost unbearable ordeal. A British GP examined Jolie's scars.
There were scars on her shins "which I suspect may be related to beatings that
she had had". Of those on her ankles and knee, he said: "The scarring appears
consistent with the story that she was repeatedly hit with a stick on her legs
and her feet were tied together by a rope." After examining her hands he
concluded: "The nail beds of the right index and middle fingers had been
destroyed and there was also extensive scarring with destruction of the nail of
the right thumb, whilst the right ring and little fingers were also slightly
deformed." Despite the physical evidence, her case was turned down. Her account
of her escape was dismissed as "implausible" and her story of ill treatment in
prison was not believed. Jolie was told in a letter from the Home Office: "With
regard to your allegation of being beaten, tortured and raped, the Secretary of
State notes that you have provided no corroborative evidence to support this
statement. He would expect anyone who had been raped to have received medical
treatment for their ordeal. However, you stated at interview that you did not
receive any medical treatment. In light of the information above, the Secretary
of State is unable to attach any credence to your claim." The Country
Information Policy Unit (CIPU) produces reports for the UK Government. CIPU
states: "The Government's human rights record is poor although there have been
improvements in some areas. Citizens do not have the right to change their
government peacefully. The security forces have been responsible for unlawful
killings, torture, beatings, rape, extortion and other abuses. In general, the
security forces have committed these abuses with impunity. The law forbids
torture but in practice security forces and prison officials have used torture
and have often beaten prisoners in the process of arresting or interrogating
them. The Government has not responded to charges of inmate abuse and repeated
beatings by its security forces and prison officials. Some members of the
police, military and security forces have also raped, robbed and extorted money
from civilians." On conditions inside Makala Prison, CIPU states: "The
Government provides inadequate food and prisoners remain dependent on the
personal resources of family or friends. Guards demand bribes and steal food
from prisoners. Some prisoners bribe guards to receive better treatment or to
get out of work assignments. Local NGOs have reported that 146 persons died at
Makala Prison in 2002, 24 of who died after being transferred to the prison from
the custody of the Provincial Inspection of Kinshasa (IPK) and the PIR, where
they were beaten severely. Most of the remaining detainees died from
malnourishment and illness." Nowhere in the DRC could be considered safe. 3
million people are thought to have died during the last five years of a
devastating war. Laurent Kabila's son Joseph is now in power in DRC and Jolie
understandably does not feel safe to return. She fled to the US to try to stay
there but failed and was returned. Last year she was imprisoned in Yarl's Wood
Immigration Removal Centre while her deportation was arranged. On the day of her
deportation she stripped naked and refused to leave her room. She claims she was
then assaulted by officers working for Group 4, the private security firm which
runs the centre. Lawyers are bringing a civil claim on her behalf against the
Home Office and Group 4 alleging ill treatment. In the end, the pilot refused to
fly with such a distressed individual on the plane. Jolie was taken to Dungavel
Immigration Detention Centre in Scotland, from where she was given "temporary
admission". It means what it says and Jolie is still nervously awaiting her
fate. The callous tone of her rejection by the Home Office is not an isolated
case.source
1 March 2004:
TWO Latvian asylum seekers
have been deported from Scotland eight weeks before they could legally settle in
the country as economic migrants, it emerged yesterday. However, the Home Office
indicated that it would continue to pursue a hard line against failed asylum
seekers from the 10 "ascension states" which are due to join the EU on May 1. Jelena
Serenja, 21, and
Genadis Suhotskis, 31, were arrested 11 days ago
when they reported to immigration officials in Glasgow. The Home Office
confirmed to The Herald that they have subsequently been flown out of the
country. The couple, who have previously been detained in Dungavel, came to
Scotland in 2001 after claiming to have uncovered government corruption in
Latvia. Ms Serenja has a bullet wound in her shoulder which she claims was the
result of an assassination attempt. Although this was accepted by the
government, their asylum application was turned down. Friends and supporters
said they were unsure whether they have been taken to Russia or Latvia.
February 13 2004: Bridget, an
unaccompanied child refugee, came to this country nearly 3 years ago. Her age
was disputed: she herself said that she was not yet 16. She was placed in
detention at Harmondsworth for some months and was only released when the Home
Office finally accepted the recommendation of a doctor's report that she was
under age. She was then placed in B&B and began to attend College. After a few
weeks of confusion, she made a happy life for herself, made friends easily, was
an enthusiastic and devout Christian and enjoyed College, where she started a
pre-nursing course. At the end of her first College year, she got a credit and
did well in a placement at an Old People's Home. She managed her relationships
with boys with remarkable self-respect. She did show signs of post-traumatic
stress, suffering dreadful nightmares about the violent death of her mother. I
referred her to her GP, who managed to arrange some brief psychiatric treatment
for her, which was remarkably successful. Her nightmares became infrequent.
Bridget failed her appeal; She was picked up, some months after her 18th
birthday, at the coming of age party of her best friend. Both young women were
placed in the cells at Chiswick Police Station on January 25th. Bridget was kept
there until the 29th. She was not allowed home to pack, although at some point
her clothes were fetched. She was not allowed to speak to her friend; both were
kept in isolation, and she could hear her friend screaming and crying. On 29th
Bridget was moved to Bedford. The night after arrival she phoned me to say that
she was to be deported early the following morning to Ghana, which is not her
country of origin. It was a Friday (January 30th) and everything was closed for
the weekend, but I spent the evening trying to get her deportation to Ghana
stopped. I took legal advice, and was told to advise Bridget that she should
refuse deportation to Ghana, but say that she would accept, without demur,
deportation to Sierra Leone, from where she had come. Somehow I was successful
in halting her deportation. The following day at dawn, she was taken to Heathrow
by van, waited for much of the day and then, without any explanation, was driven
to Manchester, where she was held in the cells at the airport overnight. By this
time she was exhausted and very distressed. She phoned me again and I explained
what I thought was happening. On 2nd February, she was driven to Dungavel in
Scotland. When she phoned, she was completely disoriented and crying. She had
been told that an Immigration Officer was looking into the evidence about her
country of origin. The following day I phoned her and she sounded quite unlike
the Bridget I knew - quiet and listless. This continued; she did not bounce
back, as I had come to expect. On February 13, I received a call from an unknown
young man in Ghana. He had been deported with Bridget the previous day, and was
picked up from the airport by his family. He gave me the number of the detention
centre where Bridget was being held, and asked me to phone her. I telephoned
immediately and was allowed to speak to Bridget, who was fearful that she would
be kept in prison indefinitely. She was being held in a cell with not even a mat
on which to sleep - just a dirty concrete floor. She had been refused access to
her clothing, and was still in the woollen clothes she had needed in Scotland;
she had not been able to wash for 2 days. She said she would kill herself. I was
able to speak to an Immigration Officer, who reassured me that they were
planning to send her on to Sierra Leone within days, when an aircraft was flying
to Freetown; I then spoke to Bridget again, and told her to hold on -. things
would come right. I made sure she had the contact address in Sierra Leone, which
I had obtained for her. As her parents are dead, she had no one to meet her. I
phoned Ghana each day, but was not allowed to speak to her again. She was, I
believe, sent on to Sierra Leone on 18th February. I have heard nothing since,
and am very concerned about her current welfare.
source
January 22, 2004: AN unemployed fisherwoman provided sanctuary in
her home for a 58 -year-old Russian woman who has spent nearly two years in
Dungavel detention centre.
Maria Ramanova, who does not speak any
English, was released into the care of Lisa McCaffrey, a 26-year-old single
mother of two from Ullapool, who came forward after hearing of her prolonged
incarceration. Ms Ramanova, who applied for asylum in 1999, was arrested after
mistakenly believing a work permit she was originally granted from the
government at the time of her application gave her permission to remain in the
United Kingdom. Prior to July 2002, asylum seekers were allowed to work if their
application for asylum was outstanding for six months. Ms Ramanova was
arrested in May 2002 in Crawley, Sussex, and has remained in custody since then
despite the Home Office not being able to provide any evidence she is at risk of
absconding. This is one of the main reasons cited by the government for
detaining asylum seekers. Yesterday, at a hearing at the immigration appellate
office in Glasgow, applause broke out after a Home Office adjudicator decided
she should be released on bail immediately. Ms Ramanova will now live in
Ullapool with Ms McCaffrey and her two children, Nina, eight, and Hamish, four,
and report to local police once a week until a final decision is made on her
appeal to stay in the UK. Ms McCaffrey, who has been corresponding with Ms
Ramanova through letters and telephone calls with the aid of interpreters, said
her family was pleased to have at last secured her release.
"I just felt that it was rotten that people who come to Scotland should be
treated like this. Scotland is not meant to be like this,"
she said.
December 8, 2003: An Iranian couple claim they were brutally beaten
by security guards while being forcibly removed from Dungavel Detention Centre.
Sarah
Shafaie, who has a heart condition, claims
she and her husband were repeatedly assaulted en route from Dungavel to
Heathrow. Sarah Shafaie said: "One of them put her leg in my neck and and
pressed me on the chair, and one of them pulling my hair, and I'm just crying
and screaming." Twenty one year old Sarah Shafaie is now back in Dungavel with
her husband Iman, after immigration authorities temporarily abandoned their
attempt to deport them. She claims that this was because the pilot refused to
fly after witnessing the treatment they received at the hands of security
guards. Sarah Shafaie added: "They be very very angry, and one of them pushed my
head on the wall." A spokesman for the Home Office said the allegations are
being referred to the police. He stressed "Clearly we would find the use of any
excessive force to be completely unacceptable." In Glasgow, Sarah's sister and
brothers, who are also seeking asylum, are growing increasingly concerned for
Sarah and Iman's safety.
Bahareh Shafaie,
Sarah's sister, said: "I'm really really worried about my sister, about her
health, about their souls, because they hurted their souls as well. she can't
sleep, she's just phoning me all the time, she's just crying ."
The Ay Family, Detained for one year and 19 days inside Dungavel,
Deported to Germany on December 2, 2003: Shortly after
half-past nine on the morning of Tuesday, August 5, Beriwan Ay was
escorted by two immigration officials - one on each side, with their arms looped
through hers - from a minibus on the runway at Stansted Airport up the steps
onto flight EXS6770, bound for Frankfurt. She was taken to her seat next to a
security officer in a cordoned-off section at the front of the specially
chartered plane, away from the other failed asylum-seekers already on board. She
was 14. The officials returned to the minibus for the rest of her family. One by
one her sister Newroz, 13, their brother Dilovan, 12,
eight-year-old and finally their mother, Yurdugal, were
accompanied aboard the jet. It was the children's first time on an aeroplane,
yet they were not allowed to sit beside each other and were instead each placed
next to their own personal security guard. Medya, remembering TV footage
of two aeroplanes flying into the twin towers, was terrified. In tears, she
pleaded with the officers to let her sit with her mother. They said sorry, but
they could not allow it. When Medya became quite hysterical, they relented and
decided it would be safe to move her to a seat next to her sister Beriwan.
Mrs Ay was warned that if she caused any trouble she and her children would
have to be handcuffed. At 10.12am flight EXS6770 took off, flying past the
airport's Union Jack fluttering gently in the summer breeze, and accelerating
into the bright blue sky. After four years, one month and 17 days in Great
Britain, the final quarter of it locked up behind reinforced steel fences and
razor-sharp barbed wire in Dungavel detention centre, a former Victorian prison
in Scotland's South Lanarkshire countryside, the family of Kurdish
asylum-seekers from Turkey were deported back to Germany to begin the next round
in their battle to find a safe place to call home. In their wake they left a
fierce debate about New Labour's policy of detaining innocent children without
limit of time. Opponents pointed out that Britain was the only country in Europe
to do so; and stressed that in Scotland, someone accused of a serious criminal
offence such as murder could only be detained for a maximum of 150 days without
being brought to trial. The Ays (pronounced like eye) were held in detention in
Britain for a longer time than any other asylum-seeking children. For one year
and 19 days they shared a room of 13 square feet with their mother in the family
unit at Dungavel, into which they were locked for 22 hours a day. If they
wanted, they could attend "school" - one classroom in the family unit staffed by
one teacher for all pupils irrespective of age or ability - but it was not
compulsory and they could, if they preferred or if their mother allowed it,
watch TV or stay in bed all day. In January, Harry Zeitlin, a well-respected
emeritus professor of child and adolescent psychiatry at University College,
London, examined the children and concluded that they had, to all intents and
purposes, been held as prisoners in a high-security jail. The environment could
be highly damaging, he added, and he called for their urgent release. According
to other medical experts, all the children suffered psychological trauma. Newroz's hair began to fall out; she also developed a hand tremor, stopped
eating and practically stopped talking. Teachers at her school in Kent, where
the family had lived during their first three years in Britain, had described
her as an exceptional pupil. Dilovan became confrontational and withdrawn; Medya
tearful and clingy; and Beriwan, an intelligent girl who speaks three languages
and had initially been the most robust, began to lose her resilience too. "It
has not been a good year for us," reflects Beriwan, a polite but feisty
teenager, now 15, who has become the translator, emotional crutch and self
-appointed spokeswoman for her family. We are with Beriwan, 14-year-old Newroz
(pronounced Nev-roz), Dilovan and Ingrid Wanka, an English and biology teacher,
at their school, Duale Oberschule, in Kirchen, a prim and orderly village 65km
east of Cologne. While the children are having their photographs taken, their
teacher asks me, almost in a whisper, whether it is true that they were locked
up while in Scotland. She shakes her head in disbelief. Last month, when she
asked the children to tell her about the country, she says Newroz started to cry
and Dilovan remained silent. After some encouragement, Beriwan told her a little
about Dungavel. "It is very shocking, disgusting, to do that to children," says
Wanka. "Children are always unguilty and should never be punished for what their
parents are doing. I think maybe Dilovan can't speak about it. The girls can,
maybe because they are a little older, but Dilovan, he is silent." She says
Dilovan in particular is struggling at school because his German is so rusty.
"The girls are trying very hard to understand and learn the language. But I've
never heard a German word from the boy." When the photographer is finished,
Beriwan begins, unprompted, to reflect again on the past year. There is a little
more anger in her voice now and, when she recalls the experience, the words
tumble from her mouth like boulders careering down a mountain. "That year in
Dungavel, it was the worst of my life because I've never been in a prison before
or a detention centre. That was my first time, and I feel very sad that I wasted
one year of my life. When I was small I saw loads of bad things, but in Dungavel
every single day was terrible. Nobody can imagine what it was like. The British
people can't imagine. It's very difficult to say how it feels. It's not just
because of the fences or because the officers come with those chains with all
the keys on them. It's loads of other stuff as well. Do you know, because we all
shared a room, me and Newroz, if we needed toiletries and stuff, we would have
to ask the guards? We couldn't go outside for fresh air when we wanted and, when
we did go out, all we could see was the sky and the fences and the barbed wire.
That was our whole world and even at Christmas you didn't really know it was
Christmas because we were still kept inside. Santa came with some presents and
we had a special Christmas dinner, so for some hours we were happy, but after
everything finished the pain just came right back." Beriwan is a pretty,
dark-haired teenager with pristine manners and a level of maturity that defies
her age. When she has finished talking, she looks at me with big, warm brown
eyes full of tears. She shakes her head and begins to sob quietly. In Scotland,
the plight of the Ay family provoked unprecedented outrage among church and
union leaders, cross-party politicians, children's charities and a wide swath of
the general public. It also gave devolution its most difficult hour as Scottish
Executive ministers observed a rigid vow of silence on the grounds that
legislative responsibility for immigration was a Home Office matter and
therefore nothing to do with them. Their impotence led Bill Speirs, general
secretary of the STUC, to compare Dungavel to Guantanamo Bay as a pocket of land
under outside rule where local laws did not apply. Most tellingly, ten days
after the family's deportation, Anne Owers, the government's own chief inspector
of prisons, stated in a long-delayed report on Dungavel that children should be
held in detention centres in exceptional circumstances only and for a very short
period - "no more than a matter of days". Such pleas, however, fell on deaf ears
at the Home Office. Battered by a right -wing press which had managed to create
the perception that every asylum-seeker was bogus, a terrorist or an
HIV-carrier, and alarmed by the rising popularity of the extremist British
National Party, David Blunkett, the home secretary, and Beverley Hughes, the
immigration minister, were determined to demonstrate that their government had a
firm grip on this most controversial of political issues. They repeatedly
justified the family's detention on the grounds that their mother was a "serial
absconder" and that she was ''stringing out" the appeals process - a process
created by their own government. When the pressure intensified, Hughes said
there were only two options: to separate the children from their parents and
take them into care, or to keep them together. In an interview on September 24,
she told me: "I believe profoundly that the best place for the children is with
their parents and to separate them would be unconscionable. I couldn't actually
do that." Yet none of those protesting had ever suggested that the children
should be split up from their mother. Instead, campaigners had recommended
cheaper, more humane alternatives such as bail with reporting conditions or
accommodating families in hostels run by churches and the voluntary sector
rather than private, profit-making companies. Sarah Cutler, a policy and
research officer with the charity Bail for Immigration Detainees, the only
organisation in Britain to have carried out research into the detention of
asylum-seeking families, said the government's main justification for detaining
families was fundamentally flawed. "There is no evidence to show that the
families are likely to abscond. On the contrary, our research shows that a
mother with four young children whose pictures have been splashed in the
newspapers are extremely unlikely to try to hide." The Ay family's behaviour
during their four and a half months in Germany supports her argument. They have
made no attempts to evade the authorities and have enjoyed relative freedom -
living in the community, attending the local school and registering with the
police once a month while their new asylum application is processed. The school
of the three older children is four kilometres from their home. They walk there
and back every day because money is tight and bus passes are considered a
luxury. When their mother asked the headteacher if they could be given bus
tickets, he said no - but added that because they were asylum -seekers, it did
not matter if they did not bother attending school. That they do is testament to
their fierce desire for an education. We leave their school and join them on the
long walk home. Dilovan clearly relishes having another boy to chat to. He
offers to carry one of the photographer's lens cases and they saunter ahead,
discussing, among other things, the fortunes of Celtic. Meanwhile, Beriwan and
Newroz talk about their life in Germany and their worries for their mother. Last
week, says Beriwan, she translated a letter from her GP. "I think she's not very
well," she says. The family's latest home is a large, sparsely furnished three-bedroomed
flat on the edge of Kirchen. The walls of the sitting room are adorned with
photographs of the children with their father in Kent; and of Mrs Ay's brothers
and sisters, all of whom have been given asylum in other European countries. In
the UK, several people blamed Mrs Ay for the prolonged detention of her
children. When I asked Beverley Hughes earlier this year if she had any regrets
about the way the family were treated in the UK, she said I should remember that
the four children were born on the move. "The family had a history of
absconding. It was necessary to detain them and what happened after detention
was really as a result of decisions they took." It was not only Home Office
ministers who felt Mrs Ay was responsible. Muriel Gray, a columnist with the
Sunday Herald, argued that Dungavel was a short-term detention centre and that
the "well -meaning people" who feared for the Ay family should have taken their
protests directly to Mrs Ay, "for it was she who made sure they stayed put and
not the immigration officers who wanted them quickly returned to where they
legally belonged". In one respect she was right. Under the terms of the Dublin
Convention - under which asylum-seekers in Europe are supposed to be dealt with
in their first country of entry - the Ay family had no legal right to remain in
the UK, not just because they entered the country illegally in the back of a
lorry but because they were "third-country applicants". In other words, they had
previously tried, and failed, to get asylum in another European country.
However, human rights organisations argued that the German authorities had a
history of disregarding the situation in Turkey and rejecting asylum
applications. The children's father, Salih, was deported to Germany in March
2002, then to Instanbul in May. The family has heard nothing of him since.
According to Mrs Ay, she and her husband fled their home town of Sirnak, a
village in the south -east of Turkey which was under a state of emergency
between 1987 and 2002, after she lost her first baby when she was imprisoned by
military police. Beriwan is sitting on one side of her mother, with Newroz on
the other. Both have a protective hand on her lap. Dilovan has gone out to play
football and Medya is imitating the photographer. Translating for her mother,
Beriwan says: "My mum was eight months pregnant with my big sister. It was her
first baby and one day the police came to my mum's house and said, 'Where's your
husband?' My mum said, 'He's not here,' so they took my mum to the police
station and they pushed her and said bad languages. Then they put her in a
freezing cell for some days. After that my dad came and said, 'Why did you take
my wife?' So they took my dad and freed my mum, but because it was so freezing
she lost her baby. The next year, when my mum was four months pregnant with me,
my mum and dad said not again and they decided to leave Turkey." It is
impossible to corroborate Mrs Ay's story. However, Kerim Yildiz, the executive
director of the Kurdistan Human Rights Project, says Kurdish people are still
denied their basic human rights in Turkey. "Sirnak is well-known for being one
of the areas where Kurds are most persecuted. The majority of Kurdish women who
are taken into detention are also sexually assaulted, and being hosed with
frozen water or kept in frozen conditions is not unusual." Although none of the
Ay children was born in Turkey - two were born in Germany and two in Greece -
all have traditional Kurdish names. Newroz translates from the Kurdish language
as "new day", and refers to the first day of spring, when the Kurdish new year
begins. According to Yildiz, a widespread campaign for the right of Kurds to
speak in the Kurdish language and use Kurdish names continues to lead to arrests
in Turkey. He also claims that failed asylum-seekers are routinely arrested and
interrogated on their return to the country. "There is a law in Turkey banning
people from criticising Turkey abroad. People are not allowed to insult the
Turkish state, the Turkish republic or the founder of the Turkish republic.
There is a strong likelihood that Mr Ay will have been detained when he returned
to Turkey and questioned. The fact he has since disappeared suggests he may
still be in prison." Beriwan and Newroz agree that life in Germany is far better
than the time they spent in Scotland. "It's better because we're free to go to
school," says Beriwan. "And it's much better than if we are sent to Turkey but
we still don't know if we're allowed to stay, so I'm still scared. I'm scared of
seeing the police. Sometimes they arrive in school for some other troubles but I
think they've come to pick me up." Beriwan still dreams of becoming a lawyer but
says she is not sure she'll make it. "The system in Germany is different from
England. I think you get a few chances in England but not that many in Germany,
and I don't think I could become a lawyer here in Germany because if you don't
have a passport you can't get a good job. But in England it's not like that. I
would like to go to university in England, then get a job and settle down."
Newroz, who is quieter and more introspective, still hopes to become a doctor.
In a quiet voice, she says: "Sometimes when I go to bed it reminds me of
Dungavel. In the morning when I wake up I open my eyes and I have to look around
to see if I'm still in the detention centre. I still get so nervous because you
never know, when the phone goes, what the news is going to be. And every day
when I walk home from school, I look up at the window ledge - that's where my
mum will have put any mail - and I wonder if it's got bad news." Having devoted
their lives to the search for somewhere to call home, it is not surprising that
Beriwan and Newroz observe their contemporaries with an unsympathetic curiosity. "Do you know," Beriwan says quizzically, "that there are girls who get very
upset because they have split up with their boyfriend? I think, oh my God,
people worry about such stupid little things. All my life I've been running and
sometimes hiding, like a timid little mouse from a big fat hungry black cat,
scared of being caught and sent 'home' to a country I've never even seen. It's a
weird life. It's a horrible life." I tell her she has been through more in her
15 years than most people experience in a lifetime and say she is very strong.
She shakes her head. "I don't really have any choice," she says, before leaning
towards her mum to give her a kiss.
December 02, 2003:
Three Algerian asylum seekers carry out a roof top protest at the Dungavel
Centre in Lanarkshire. Names unknown.
Use of force on a Congolese
women 25th Oct 2003: The Mirror journalist described what one of the Group4
DCSs working at Yarl’s Wood during the time covered by the Yarl’s Wood VC report
allegedly said to recent new Group4 recruits in a training session - "[DCS Mr D]
told the trainees about some trouble over the previous weekend. A Congolese
woman identified as Ms A was being deported. She was taken into the
Removal from Association area in case she started to 'play up'. [DCS Mr D] said:
'We were taking a detainee into RFA on Saturday because we had got intelligence
on her. But one shift manager decided that only female DCOs would be in the C&R
team. So three females went in and two got hurt. One was bitten. So we changed
it and two males and a female went in and splattered her.'". The Congolese
detainee was naked and a male Group4 staff took her legs - the Prison
Service's leading exponent of C&R training said he did not see a need for the
[Group4] men to become involved. The Congolese detainee does not know
what the so-called “intelligence” on her was and told us that Group4 refused to
tell her where she was being taken – she was later taken to the airport for
removal and she claims she was not given any Removal Notice, so the removal
would have been in breach of Immigration Notices Regulations 2003 section 4.1.
She says the Air France pilot refused to allow her and the immigration escorts
to fly as she was inadequately dressed and screaming in fear. That all
happened in the early hours of the Saturday morning. The detainee says she was
returned to Yarl’s Wood around 10pm the same day and was put straight into
Segregation before being transferred to Dungavel Removal Centre around 6pm
Sunday.
Source
October 2003:
10-year-old Ukrainian, Kostya Loban, and his parents are released after
three weeks detention inside Dungavel Removal Centre. Kostya was woken by an
arrest team in his Glasgow bedroom in early October and taken to the detention
centre near Strathaven. His parents, Aleksander, who is a Christian, and
Tanya, who is Jewish, maintain that
they cannot return to the Ukraine because they fear race and religious
persecution. Kostya recalled how his first reaction had been to hide under
the duvet when he woke to find four uniformed men in his bedroom. The arrest
team, some of whom were said to be wearing bulletproof vests, handcuffed
Kostya's father, while his mother was searched and undressed in the bathroom. he
three were then taken by three women and around six men in two police vans to
Dungavel. During the 40-minute journey, Kostya vomited. I was scared," said the
young Ukrainian, now in his 10th day of detention. "They treated me bad. They
shouted 'Get up, get dressed, sit down'. It was like being in the army. They
wouldn't let me take pictures, my toys, or my pencils." But most distressing, he says, was
the moment officers asked him to choose between his parents. "I picked my mum
because she was crying most. I didn't know
where we were going. It made me feel bad." He added: "Why am I in jail? I don't
want to fly away. I want to go back to my school and my teacher." Kostya Loban
was one of four children under the age of 11 who were detained in the former
prison in South Lanarkshire.
November 7, 2003: Fetnet Pllana, 33, and her three children, who were
being held at the Dungavel Detention Centre in Lanarkshire, were yesterday
ordered on to a flight to Germany where the authorities are expected to return
them to Kosovo. But yesterday, five years after arriving in Britain to
start a new life as a family, their plans lay in tatters. Mrs Pllana fled Kosovo
in 1992 with her three children Hotman, nine, Lora, eight, and
Labinet, six. Speaking at Dungavel days before she was deported, Mrs Pllana
said: 'I am shocked at the way we have been treated. I do not want to have to go
back to Kosovo. My children have no future there.' Scottish Socialist MSP
Rosie Kane said the mother and three children had grown accustomed to life in
Britain and it was inhumane to move them.
September 22, 2003:
Three weeks of uncertainty fear and being kept in a former prison have finally
come to an end for a family of Kosovan asylum seekers.
Rosa Tusha
together with her children Alfred nine Armand six and Veronica
three were released from the Dungavel immigration centre in Scotland on Friday
to the relief of campaigners who have battled for their freedom. Officials
swooped on the family's home in St Leonard's Road Southend last month and after
being taken to Southend police station and Oakington Reception Centre
Cambridgeshire the family were moved to Dungavel. Now thanks to the efforts of
solicitor Sally McEwen and volunteers Jan Noble and June Manzoini from the
Clarence Road-based group Churches and Refugees Together the family are back
home in south Essex.
September 12, 2003:
Bushra Sharif
and her
three children, Abdullah, 7, Talal, 6, and Bassam, 13
months, are released on bail after being held for more than three weeks in
Dungavel. They were granted refugee status in August last year after an
adjudicator ruled Mrs Sharif had a well-founded fear of persecution and had been
involved in an abusive marriage. Her lawyer has applied for a judicial review.
Abdullah's own words
September 4,2003:
Mercy
Ikolo
and her one-year-old daughter
Percieliz
are released from
Dungavel Removal Centre after a campaign begun by Positive Action in Housing and
taken up by the Sunday Herald. Rosie Kane MSP agreed to provide a home for
Mercy which allowed the mother and child to be freed.
September 4, 2003: A MOTHER held inside a controversial detention centre
for asylum seekers has been fined her £3.50 basic weekly allowance for taking
food to her room to feed her children. Somalian mother- of- two
Fatima
Jailana Muse was fined the weekly allowance by Dungavel bosses for a series
of trivial offences, including taking Weetabix to her room to feed her
one-year-old child. Mrs Muse, 33, is one of several mothers who complain they
are finding it difficult to feed their children because of the rigid regime
inside the Lanarkshire detention centre. The women claim the last food available
is at 5.30pm, with nothing else until the morning, despite the centre housing
children as young as one. Food is not allowed to be taken into the rooms,
leaving many complaining their children are in danger of becoming malnourished. Mrs Muse claims her daughters Nasra, one, and Nasteho, who will be three on
Saturday, were not eating properly at the specified meal times, forcing her to
take the cereal to her room. She added: 'My baby is small and she has trouble
eating.' The latest controversy at Dungavel follows a report by the Chief
Inspector of Prisons last month which criticised some aspects of the regime. The
former prison, run by the private company Premier Detention Services, holds up
to 148 failed asylum seekers and other immigration detainees. Last week there
was a record number of 23 children at the centre, although seven have since been
deported. The HM Chief Inspector's Report said the long-term detention of
children in immigration removal centres must stop and described facilities for
school age children as 'unsatisfactory'. A Home Office spokesman said food
was not allowed to be eaten in rooms for hygiene reasons. He added: 'Mothers can bottlefeed their babies in their room and milk kitchens are provided for them in
addition to the canteen facilities.'
more
September 3, 2003:
WHEN 18-month-old Destina Polat was taken into detention, the first thing
officers did was photograph her and take her finger-prints. She was giggling,
according to her parents, Ibrahim and Donus, because she thought
it was some kind of game. Her parents, however, Kurdish asylum seekers from
Turkey who lived in the south side of Glasgow for two-and-a-half years before
being detained, were crying and distressed. Donus, 22, her mother, said she
refused food and water for six days. The baby is one of 17 children held at
Dungavel immigration removal centre, a former prison in South Lanarkshire.
Speaking through an interpreter, Mrs Polat said: "I was begging them to let my
baby out, to keep me here if they wanted, but to let my baby out and to give her
to her uncle (who lives in Edinburgh). "But they said if I couldn't look after
her they would look after her so I started to eat." Ghazala Ahmed, a lawyer
representing Donus Polat has also raised concerns about detainees access to
foodstuffs for their children: "I'm very concerned because although the
authorities say detainees have access to milk 24 hours a day, it is kept in a
locked room, and there is no interpreter."
September 3, 2003: An Iranian asylum-seeker, was kept in isolation
for four days after he threw a plate. He was vomiting blood, passing blood and
his nose was bleeding. When his lawyer saw him he was doubled over in pain but
he was put in an isolation unit. (Source: Herald)
August 23, 2003:
In a previous contract with the private
providers of the facilities at Dungavel, the government included a clause on
education provision, which read: "The contractor will establish a programme of
activities which will include primary and secondary education devised in
conjunction with the local education authority which meets the needs of relevant
education."
At Dungavel, pupils can expect between four and five hours teaching a day. One full-time teacher is employed to cater for 21 pupils aged from 5 to 18, as
well as a nursery worker for younger pupils. Parents can opt their children out
of education at any time.
A spokesperson for the Home Office said that there was no national commitment
to providing education for asylum seekers because of the particular needs of the
demographic, meaning that the national picture has to be "flexible". He
emphasised that in the case of Dungavel 80% of children spent under six weeks at
the centres and only 3% were remained for over 14 weeks. He added that the 3%
was largely attributable to the Ay family, a Kurdish family of four children who
were last week deported to Germany after spending over a year in Dungavel -
causing the chief inspector of prisons, Anne Owers, to condemned the use of
detention centres to house children. (Source)
August 15, 2003:

Not forgotten -
Click
here to see the Ay family's page - the children's story, drawings and pictures
ONE in five of the inmates at
Scotland's detention centre for asylum seekers are children. Dungavel House in
South Lanarkshire has been criticised by prison and education watchdogs for
locking up children - some under the age of five - and failing to educate them
properly. A report by Anne Owers, Her Majesty's Chief Inspector of Prisons, said
17 per cent of detainees are 16 or under. It revealed that children were forced
to spend 'many months' in the centre - and that the education provided for them
at taxpayers' expense fell seriously short of basic standards. It also painted a
shambolic picture of the whole asylum system, which it said is open to abuse.
The report comes in the wake of the controversial case of the Ay family
of Kurdish asylum seekers, including four children, who were smuggled into
Britain four years ago. They were held at Dungavel for a year and finally
deported last week after costing taxpayers more than 500,000. Dungavel holds
those detained by the Immigration Service as overstayers, illegal entrants or
failed asylum seekers. It also holds some detainees whose cases have not yet
been determined, but are at risk of absconding. The report said: 'Seventeen per
cent of the (106) detainees at the time of the inspection were children (up to
16 years old). We came across families who had spent months in the centre. There
were serious shortfalls in educational provision. In addition, because families
and children were locked into the family unit, they needed to ask staff if they
wished to go out; at the time of the inspection, children had insufficient play
areas and outside access.' Two-thirds of detainees had been in detention
elsewhere. The report said: 'Some appeared to be shunted up and down the country
in a way that demonstrated little strategic planning and little concern for
either their welfare as people or the public purse.' One family arrived at
Dungavel from Harmondsworth Detention Centre in West London - a journey of
roughly 400 miles. They spent one day at Dungavel before being taken to
Manchester Airport Detention Centre, where they spent the night. They were then
sent to Tinsley House - only 43 miles from Harmondsworth. The report revealed
children are used as interpreters at Dungavel. One young girl translated as her
father described how he had been attacked and beaten by Serbian police. She
broke down and the interview was called off. The report calls for changes to
the system to make detention of children 'an exceptional course - no more than a
matter of days'. A separate report released yesterday by Her Majesty's
Inspectorate of Education backed this view. Home Office Minister Hazel Blears
said: 'It is regrettable that families with children have to be detained at all,
but it is the actions of the adults in the families that make this necessary. It
is not typical for families to be detained for a long time. Those that are have
often strung out the appeals process and exhausted all legal right to remain in
this country.'
Dec 3 2002
Janet
McGregor wed her fiance
Amir Fayyaz inside dungavel Removal Centre after
immigration officials seized him fours days before the planned ceremony.
Now the mum-of-five is fighting a bid to deport her husband in less than two
weeks' time. The 35-year-old fears Amir, 31, will be killed if he is sent back
to Pakistan. Janet said: "I would end up a widow, I am sure of it. "If Amir gets
sent back, he will be killed because of his political beliefs. That is why he
had to leave." She added: "I couldn't live without Amir now and I will do
everything in my power to make sure he stays in Scotland." Janet, of Tamfourhill,
Falkirk, said she has known Amir for three years and the relationship blossomed
into romance a year and a half ago. She said immigration officials burst into
her home last week and took her husband- to-be away in an early-morning raid.
Janet said: "We were asleep when they came and just took him away without an
explanation. Janet had planned to wed Amir at Falkirk Register's Office but
switched the ceremony to Dungavel Detention Centre in Lanarkshire. She said: "We
had our wedding day last Wednesday and I got to spend six hours with him but we
weren't allowed to be alone. "The kids and myself have visited him every day but
they won't let us kiss or cuddle him." Janet said her lawyer planned to appeal
against Amir's deportation on December 15. Last night, a spokesman for Falkirk West Labour
MP Eric Joyce said: "The staff at Dungavel should be congratulated for carrying
out the wedding, given the circumstances. "Eric has visited Dungavel and is
convinced the regime is fair and robust. "He
will continue to look into the circumstances surrounding this case."
November 5, 2002:
Lord Avebury took up the case of Jaqueline Kunan, an asylum seeker from
Ivory Coast. Her case was reported on "Woman's Hour" yesterday morning. She was
in Harmondsworth from June, then detained in Dungavel, and then returned to
Harmondsworth on 21 October. She has had three solicitors, one of whom, it
appears, did not do a particularly good job. She has with her a baby who was
born a year and a half ago, and she is again pregnant. Jaqueline Kunan's claim
is one that would normally be regarded as fundamentally unfounded, on the basis
that the judgment given by the authorities was that she had not made out her
case for asylum from Ivory Coast-a country where a military coup and takeover
have occurred. However, Lord Avebury was able to substantiate independently the
facts that the woman alleged, and in a way that made her case clear."
Source
September 14, 2002:
The average cost of detaining an asylum seeker, says the Home Office, is £29,400
a year, yet the weekly cost of holding someone at Oakington detention centre in
Cambridgeshire is £1,620 a week (around pounds 85,000 a year), according to a
parliamentary question answered in October last year. Two government-funded
companies, UK Detention Services, which runs Harmondsworth, and Premier
Custodial Services, which runs Dungavel, have a combined turnover of pounds
109,567,196. (Source: The Guardian)
September 14, 2002: Françoise, a
21-year-old from Cameroon, arrived in the UK in June 2001. She spent most of
her pregnancy in detention. When we met, she and her baby had been locked up for
five of his six months. Françoise was either sold or given away when she was
four years old, and brought up in a Muslim farming family. When she was 17, she
was told that she would become one of her foster father's wives. When she
refused, she was locked up and beaten. She ran away. On arrival in Britain, she
was held at Oakington detention centre, where asylum seekers are fast-tracked
through the process by in-house lawyers. Her asylum plea was rejected and she
was dispersed to Leeds, pending an appeal. Soon after arriving, she discovered
that she was pregnant. When Françoise got to the Leeds address given to her by
the Home Office National Asylum Support Service (Nass), she was told that there
was no room and so was sent on elsewhere. Her lawyer at the time told her that
she didn't need to inform Nass because he had her details and would keep in
touch. Her baby was born prematurely, at 34 weeks. She spent three weeks in
hospital in Leeds, then went back to the flat she'd been allocated. A week
later, "They came for me at 7am. They said, 'Your case is over, you are going
into detention.' They started to put my things into bags. I could not even tell
the health visitor that we were going." Unfortunately, her asylum paperwork had
not kept up with her and notification of her appeal hearing had been sent to the
wrong address. It was rejected without her having a chance to speak for herself.
"She fell into the gap that many dispersed and bewildered asylum seekers
experience," says her current lawyer, Eileen Bye. In Françoise's absence, her
case was turned down and she was detained pending removal. It doesn't seem to
have mattered that she knew nothing of the hearing, let alone that she had a
month-old premature baby. "How can they remove me when they have not heard my
case?" she asks. "What will happen to him if I go back? I have no money, no
family." As Bye says, "The experience of immigration detention has
difficulties beyond just deprivation of liberty. It is the uncertainty that most
undermines the spirit: they do not know how long they might be detained; they do
not know, and have reason to fear, the outcome. The sense of isolation is
heightened because they have no friends able to visit them. They're alone with
their fear and uncertainty." Françoise is very much alone and depressed.
Dungavel detention centre, where she is held at the time of writing, is way off
the beaten track - it takes seven hours from London, where her friends are, and
that's travelling by plane, bus, train and, if you're lucky, the free minibus
that goes every two hours. Dungavel is surrounded by high fences with razor
wire. It's no place for an adult, let alone a child, but for Françoise and her
baby UK detention centres have become home. Four weeks after his birth, she was
taken to Yarl's Wood in Bedfordshire, the detention centre that burned down in
February. "They were locked in when it went up in flames," says Bye, "and in the
panic and the smoke Françoise didn't know if she and the baby would survive.
Other detainees helped them escape, then they waited outside to be re-detained.
They lost everything - their few personal possessions, clothes, all her Home
Office papers and the baby's birth certificate." After Yarl's Wood, Françoise
was taken to Harmondsworth, where she suffered an attempt to put her on a plane
back to Cameroon."They came to me and said, 'Give your baby to the nurse, we
need to weigh him.' I said, 'No, I'll come to the medical centre with him if he
needs attention.' When I was there, they took him from me, then put me in the
van to the airport. They only gave him back when I was in the van. It was a
trick. But in the end there was no place for me on that plane, so they brought
me back. Because they came to take my baby, I am worried all the time, whenever
I hear keys. I can't sleep at night - a small noise and I'm awake. I walk around
at night. Just walk, walk." After three months at Harmondsworth, they came for
her again early one morning and took her to Dungavel. There was no explanation.
"You don't have any information about when you will be moved or released,"
says Françoise. "You don't know if tomorrow you're going to be here. In the
night, neighbours disappear. They told me detention is not prison, but it is.
You can't see people, get fresh air. You can't enjoy your baby. Tell me, why
should they keep us here? How can I run away when I have a baby and no money?"
source
September 2, 2002: Health: Records of maternal and infant health are not
available. With some asylum seekers put in detention on arrival and others
placed in emergency accommodation or induction centres, maternal health is poor.
Average birth weight of asylum seekers' babies is significantly lower than the
norm, with higher rates of perinatal mortality. Detainees in Dungavel Centre are
paid GBP 1 a week. Detention: A recent Scottish parliamentary visit to Dungavel
removal centre found there was "no justification for the detention of children"
and that the detainees had committed no crimes. It also noted there was a
failure to collect statistics, for example on self-harm. Statistics like these
and the number of pregnant asylum-seekers are key in monitoring the
asylum-seeking system. (Source: The Scotsman)
July 30, 2002: The
number of children held will increase significantly from those currently
imprisoned in the 300 "family rooms" at Harmondsworth, in Middlesex,
and Dungavel, in Scotland.
These places are far from cosy: they have security equivalent to category B
prisons, uniformed officers roam the corridors, nurseries look out to high walls
topped with razor wire. (Source: The
Guardian)
June 3, 2002:
Nikola Garza
and her family were hoping for a life free of violence and intimidation when
they arrived in Britain in March, 2001, from their native Slovakia. Nikola's
mother Agata Garza, 34, and her husband, Dusan, 32, are members of the Romani
minority, traditionally travellers, who are still persecuted in Eastern Europe.
Nikola, 13, and her brother,
Adrian,
12, were considered mixed -race and were picked on at school in their home town
of Kosice. When Agata was pregnant with baby Vanesa, she was attacked by racist
skinheads while out shopping in Kosice. Vanesa was born two months prematurely
as a result and suffered brain damage. Now almost two, Vanesa has impaired
vision and hearing, cannot talk, or even crawl. After their arrival in Britain
last year, the family was eventually housed in a flat in Gateshead - after
spending weeks in other English towns - while their plea for asylum was
considered. They settled well and made friends. Adrian and Nikola, without a
word of English on arrival, fared well at school and Nikola was placed on a
national register for academically gifted children. Vanesa began to get the
medical attention she desperately needed, and her condition - as did the plight
of the whole family - attracted media attention. Early in March this year, the
family's Gateshead flat was entered by immigration officers who gave them an
hour to pack before taking them to Dungavel, a former prison in Ayrshire, now a
detention centre for asylum -seekers. Six weeks later, the scene was played out
again and the family was moved to Harmondsworth, a detention centre in
Middlesex, where they were on the verge of being deported. The family's initial
application for asylum was made in Dusan's name and was rejected, as was a
subsequent appeal. The family's lawyer, Azmina Hansraj, had to find another way
to prevent the deportation. She made a fresh application on Vanesa's behalf this
time. While immigration officials refused to consider it, a judge intervened at
the last minute and said the new application had to be considered. A few days
later, the family was allowed to return to Gateshead. Although they are
technically not prisoners, because they have left a detention centre, they have
been granted bail, which has been put up for them by the Moon family (see diary,
below). The legal process, meanwhile, grinds on. The following is Nikola Garza's
view of her time spent under the control of the British authorities.
NIKOLA'S DIARY
GATESHEAD, 9 MARCH, 2002 IT WAS 7: 30 in the morning. There was a knock on the
door. Everybody was asleep, except for my Dad (Dusan) and me. He opened the door
and saw six or seven people in front of him. He was nervous because he didn't
know what was happening. One of the men said: "I am from immigration, they have
sent me to get you to Scotland. You have got one hour to pack your things." Then
a police officer entered the house and came into my bedroom. I was so scared of
him. I thought this was surely a dream. Then I stood up and wanted to put my
clothes on, but they wouldn't let us be by ourselves. In every room there was an
immigration person or policeman. I went to the toilet and I put my clothes on.
Then I went to my Mum's (Agata's) room, grabbed a suitcase and started to pack
my clothes. Then I put my little sister, Vanesa's clothes on and put her back in
the cot. We didn't know what was happening. I was so scared and so was my
family. We got all our bags packed and were taken out of the house. My Mum,
Vanesa and me got into a blue car, my brother Adrian and my Dad got into a white
police van and we were all taken to a police station. When we went in there, the
police took our pictures and checked our bags and us. One of the officers said:
"You are going to Scotland for three or four days." They gave us some papers and
we were put back in the van. It was so long a road to Scotland from Newcastle. I
took that time to think. I was thinking about all my friends and my school in
Gateshead and that I wouldn't see them again. I was nearly crying. It was so
cold in the van. My Dad asked to put the heating on.
DUNGAVEL DETENTION CENTRE We arrived at Dungavel House at three
o'clock the same day. They took our pictures and finger prints. They took us to
a little room and asked if we were hungry. We were because we hadn't had any
breakfast or lunch, but the food was horrible.
We went back to reception and they gave us our jewellery and watches back and
two officers took us to the family unit. There were two officers with us, one
called Andrea the other Sandra, and they told us they were going to get a nurse
to check that we were OK. But I wasn't listening to them, I was just thinking,
"What is happening to my family?" And my brother, he was so scared and upset. We
went to the children's activity room and played table tennis. We felt a little
bit happier then, but there were no other children there. Later they called us
to dinner and after, we went to our room and my Mum and Dad phoned a friend of
theirs asking what would happen to us now and she told us that the immigration
people were probably wanting to deport us and told us if we got any more news to
call them. 10 MARCH We woke up and went for breakfast and later we were all very
sad. Someone came and asked me what do I like to do, and I told them I like art,
so I went to the activity room and was brought lots of art stuff.
10 MARCH ONWARDS So it went,
day after day. The officers were very friendly but we always had feelings which
I can't describe. At night I always woke up thinking that I was not in my room. And there were always problems. My little sister Vanesa didn't want to eat
anything for two weeks. I think she knew that she wasn't at home. I wanted to
ask my mother what was happening but I didn't want to hurt her with my
feelings. I spent my 13th birthday in the detention centre. Every Wednesday our
loveliest family friends from Gateshead came to visit us - my auntie Joan and my
uncle, Jeff Moon. They came on my birthday and brought me a present. I love them
and don't want to lose them. Nicola and her family were then transferred from
Dungavel Detention Centre, near Strathaven, Lanarkshire, to Harmondsworth
Detention Centre in Middlesex.
HARMONDSWORTH DETENTION CENTRE,
12 APRIL Six weeks have gone by at Dungavel. Early in the morning there was a
knock at the door. A lady said to us: "You've got half an hour to get ready." My
Mum asked "Why?" The lady said we were going to another detention centre. My Mum
talked to the immigration officers and asked why we were going away. They didn't
know. After breakfast we were taken to reception and we had to get into a van
again. I was crying because I started to like this place and now were leaving.
It took about four hours to get to Manchester, then we went to an airport. We
were taken to a room somewhere and spent about six hours there. Then two
officers came and told us we were now going to London. Then we were in a van
again. It was very cold. My Mum and Dad were tired and very upset. It was the
middle of the night when we arrived at the new centre. Again they took our
things and took my Mum and Dad's pictures and finger prints. My Mum and me and my brother and
sister were told we could go to our room. My Dad was to come later, he was going
to see a nurse. I saw there were only three beds there. I asked: "Where is my
Dad going to sleep?" She said he was going to sleep on the floor, on a mat. When
my Dad came back, he was very angry. I told him I would swap with him and he
could sleep on the bed, but he said: "No." I was very tired and slept quickly.
13 APRIL We looked around the
centre and I met another girl from Slovakia. I played with her. Our family were
now given two rooms to sleep in.
14 APRIL ONWARDS It was every
day the same. I wasn't happier because my friend went back to Slovakia. At least
she understood my feelings.
7 MAY The officers called us to reception. They gave
us our bags and took us to a van. We were upset and crying. We were expecting
now to be deported. We left in the van and then the van turned around again and
went back to the centre. We were not going to be deported this time. They took
our pictures and finger prints again. Then we went back to the family unit. I
thought that perhaps no-one liked us because we are a Romani family. The
immigration people want to send us back to Slovakia because they don't like us.
I was missing my friends and my teachers in Gateshead. I have seen that in this
country, colour of the skin is not a problem, like in Slovakia.
13 MAY It was 2pm. I was
sitting in the classroom at the centre and someone came in and told me that my
Mum wanted to see me, and that were free now. I was laughing. My Mum was very
happy and told me to pack my things. Again, we were back in reception and were
given our papers and let outside. They gave us travel tickets, some money and
paid for a taxi. The taxi driver took us to King's Cross train station. We got
the 6: 41pm to Newcastle. In the train I was thinking of the Moons. I couldn't
wait to see them. When we got to Newcastle we got a taxi to their house.
Everyone was ha |